Thinking of buying a flat at Craighouse? Discover the risks you won’t see in the brochure – from resale concerns to legal and build quality issues.
The Hidden Risks of Investing in Craighouse Edinburgh
Investing in a premium property like Craighouse Edinburgh may seem like a secure bet — historic buildings, scenic views, and slick marketing. But buyers and investors are starting to raise red flags.
This isn’t speculation — these are first-hand experiences, facts from public sources, and concerns shared by legal and real estate professionals.
1. Resale Risk – Can You Actually Sell Your Craighouse Flat?
One of the most underdiscussed risks is liquidity. Craighouse is a niche product:
- Heritage site converted into flats — beautiful, but niche appeal
- Premium pricing limits the buyer pool
- High insurance premium scare off second-time buyers
Ask yourself:
“If I wanted to sell in 18 months, who would buy it from me — and at what price?”
Some buyers are already reporting difficulty securing re-sale interest, and agents are hesitant to take listings.
2. Unusual Cost Structure – Low Service Charges, But High Insurance Risks
At first glance, Craighouse may seem attractive from a cost perspective:
The service charges are relatively low compared to other premium Edinburgh developments.
That’s largely because much of the surrounding land belongs to the council, not to the owners’ association — meaning buyers aren’t footing the bill for maintaining extensive grounds.
But there’s a hidden catch:
The buildings themselves are listed heritage properties, which can bring significantly higher insurance premiums and specialist maintenance costs.
In some cases, this means:
- Limited flexibility when it comes to repairs or modifications
- Insurance requirements that exceed standard residential cover
- Unexpected costs during major works or structural upgrades
In other words, while the day-to-day service charges look attractive, buyers need to account for longer-term liabilities tied to listed building obligations.
3. Developer Conduct & Communication
One of the most cited frustrations is the developer’s transparency and responsiveness.
Buyers have reported:
- Delayed responses
- Sudden changes in unit allocation
- Incomplete or vague documentation
If you’re buying off-plan or dealing with complex heritage restorations, trust in the developer is everything. Craighouse has shown some cracks in that trust.
4. Planning Complexity – What Happens in Future Phases?
Craighouse is a multi-phase project, and that means risk:
- Delays in completion of later phases could affect noise, access, and resale
- The planning documents from Edinburgh Council reveal a long history of public objection, heritage concerns, and conditional approvals
If you’re hoping the site will be “done” and quiet in two years — be cautious.
5. Limited Control Over Common Areas
Ownership in developments like Craighouse often means you’re subject to the decisions of a management company or factors outside your control.
- Landscaping, lighting, bin storage, and parking are collectively managed
- As the site ages, costs go up — and owners are expected to absorb that
- Some buyers have raised concerns over lack of consultation on major shared costs
6. Market Saturation in the Premium Edinburgh Flat Sector
The Edinburgh market is cooling — especially in the premium segment:
- Interest rates remain high
- Buy-to-let is less attractive due to tax changes
- Many similar developments are launching
That means less capital appreciation and a longer time to sell if you need to exit.
Final Verdict: Craighouse Isn’t for Every Investor
Craighouse is beautiful — but it’s not simple.
If you’re looking for:
- Guaranteed ROI
- Flexible resale
- Stable ongoing costs
- Bulletproof construction and service
…Craighouse may not be the ideal fit.
And if you’re buying emotionally based on the setting, the branding, or the history — take a breath. Do your diligence. Ask your solicitor the hard questions. Demand answers early.
Additional Resources
- Historic Hospitals: Craighouse History
- Edinburgh Council Planning Docs
- Friends of Craighouse – Community Concerns
Have Your Own Craighouse Story?
Use our anonymous review form here to share your experience and help future buyers make informed decisions.